Where is all of the fediverse?
blog.benjojo.co.uk

The author examined the distribution of instances in the fediverse. Given that many instances are hidden behind CDNs like Cloudflare or Fastly, the author employed ActivityPub’s functionality to discover the actual hosting locations of servers. More than half (51%) of the fediverse is hosted within a single hosting company. The author suggests that the fediverse hosted mostly with a few major providers, deviates from its initial objectives.

  • TheMurphy@lemmy.worldEnglish
    712·
    10 months ago

    Whoever wrote this blog post missed the point in the way the fediverse is decentralised.

    It’s not about hosting. It’s about ownership. And that means hosting can change at any moment. Because no one company decides anything.

    That’s why we really want the fediverse. Because it’s not build for late stage capitalism and monopolies.

    • My Password Is 1234@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
      422·
      10 months ago

      You’re correct; the focal point revolves around data ownership. However, you have to ask yourself, do we actually own the data?

      Currently, four major hosting companies dominate the fediversum. Instance owners in practice do not have full control over the physical servers where their data is hosted.

      Do you own the disks on which the data is hosted? No! The hosting companies retain that ownership and, can wipe the contents with a mere click.

      A regular court order is all it takes, and I question whether every instance is backed up? While some may indeed have backups, they might reside on the very same server. Others, although having backups, may execute the process improperly. Additionally, there are those with partial backups, and the list goes on.

      • TORFdot0@lemmy.worldEnglish
        22·
        10 months ago

        Those companies don’t own your backups and can’t stop you from moving your instance somewhere else. And if you don’t have a backup then it doesn’t matter if you are running your instance in a datacenter you built yourself because you can inadvertently wipe the contents with a mere click

      • towerful@programming.devEnglish
        14·
        10 months ago

        Anyone concerned with that threat model can host their own instance on whatever hardware they want.
        They could have the middleware load balanced over aws/azure/gcp/hetzner/at-home and have load-balanced replicated postgres also running on those hosts.
        They could use CDN & threat protection from those cloud providers as well as cloudflare. And really distribute the threat of that situation.
        But nobody wants to fork out $$$ every month before they are even scaling to thousands of users, never mind the added complications of middleware from one provider trying to interact with a load balancer on another provider which is forwarding to postgres on a different provider, let alone geographic latencies.
        Then trying to manage that, never mind the headache of an update.

        But, if that is someones threat model, then they CAN work around it.

        Companies owning the actual servers and infrastructure is at the level of enormous scaling (like twitter) or high risk (like banking, even then chances are they are running hardened systems that would be secure on anything).
        Most companies will pass that responsibility off to a single provider, and rely on that providers skills/services for uptime

      • conciselyverbose@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
        5·
        10 months ago

        A regular court order won’t be granted unless there’s very good reason.

        And it won’t be issued to cloudflare to “delete everything that uses ActivityPub”, because that’s insane. And would require a bunch of manual engineering work.

        And being distributed through cloudflare tells you nothing about where the files are stored. Because they’re a CDN.

      • r00ty@kbin.life
        41·
        10 months ago

        OVH server owners learned their lesson not to keep their backups on the same hosting provider after the fire a few years ago. The only problem I had was actually getting OVH to give me a new server to restore my off-site backup to!

        If you have backups independently of your hosting provider AND your domain isn’t hosted with them. The worst they can do is take you down for the time it takes to get a new server elsewhere, restore your data and point your DNS (or CDN endpoint) to your new home.

        If you’re running a fediverse server and at the bare minimum don’t have your database backed up somewhere, then the fault of any takedown is as much your fault as your hosting provider.

        Mine is first backed up nightly to a server on another hosting provider, and that in turn is backed up to encrypted cloud backup.