• 2 Posts
  • 529 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: August 2nd, 2023

help-circle


















  • Israel has the largest Desal operation in the world with their combined facilities, and they’ve still managed to cause issues every operating year for a decade. Whether it be pipeline leaks, transport issues, or not controlling the byproducts well enough when they dilute it back to the ocean.

    What exactly does operational issues and equipment breakdown have to do with a technology being viable?

    It’s just not sustainable, and prone to error at every step.

    Pretty much everything in modern industrial processes are prone to error at every step. Somehow, we’ve figured out how to follow checklists and procedures and avoid blowing stuff up. Your statement implies incompetence among the operators more than anything else.

    Storing this stuff in a mountain like we do with toxic waste has the same implications

    Nobody has EVER suggested this, and you’ve set up a strawman argument out of thin air.

    Seriously, if people like you are what future generations are contending with in that this is “not my problem now, they’ll figure it out”, this planet is certainly fucking doomed.

    I’ve been pointing out how and why the technology can operate. You’ve been resorting to strawmen arguments and ad hominem attacks.


  • Despite your edits, I don’t see anything in the linked articles that suggests brine cannot be diluted or dissipated.

    You can’t just “put it back” in the ocean, because then you’re increasing the concentration of salinity and toxicity in a localized area and killing everything

    Not sure why you’re still insisting on this after your edit, since as several commentors have pointed out there’s no reason for you to dump it in a single localised area. Toxins and heavy metals can also be extracted, and might even be done so profitably (according to your own links, in fact).

    The only point you might have so far is Israel, since they are using a small lake as their source of water, and can’t reasonably dilute the brine. However, with seawater desalination none of these issues apply.