Some more atmospheric lighting would go miles with this. I can’t see anything in the image, well it’s hard. Too dark.

The neon in the back is almost too overpowering,but provides no actual light. It’s weird.

From what I can see looks good

Too dark, can’t see creepy.

At first, in that light, I couldn’t tell if their eyes had pupils, but I realized they did. IMO it would make the orange cat and blue bear scarier if instead of pinprick pupils they just had full-white eyes. Pretty scary as-is, though. 👍

Dial it in if you want creepy vs. scary. Make them mostly normal with an uncanny feature or two, and make those different for each one.

The post below about putting human eyes on one is a great example.