cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/15286303
GOP introduces bill that would send anyone convicted of unlawful activity on a campus since Oct. 7th, 2023 to Gaza.
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/15286301
“A group of Republican lawmakers introduced a bill on Wednesday which would send “any person convicted of unlawful activity” at a college or university, to do community service in Gaza for six months.”
“Strangely, the bill appears to refer to any “unlawful activity on the campus of an institution of higher education beginning on and after October 7, 2023” but does not specifically mention the ongoing student protests, rendering it stupidly broad.”
"Ogles spoke with Fox News about the bill, saying that, “If you support a terrorist organization, and you participate in unlawful activity on campuses, you should get a taste of your own medicine. I am going to bet that these pro-Hamas supporters wouldn’t last a day, but let’s give them the opportunity.”
Hmm. So a US law introduced solely to ‘fire up the base’ now has the agency to override any immigration/visa requirements of Gaza? American exceptionalism at its finest.
Who’s going to handle the logistics of travel, housing, and food? Is the US military going to house thousands of civilian students? or should the studennts check out Gaza’s bustling real estate listings for vacant hostels and flats?
Get busted in your dorm for getting drunk… off to Gaza?
Think of how stupid the average conservative is, then remember, half of them are stupider than that.
For the reasons you listed, among many even more fundamental ones, the would never pass, and if it did, it’s unenforceable.
It’s not to fire up the conservative base. It’s to fire you up.
It’s just bait to shape their strawman “screeching liberal” archetype. They want pictures of blue haired college LGBTQ folks frothing at the mouth, chanting “death to Republicans”
That’s all the Republicans do. It’s all they’ve done for 40 years. They’re never FOR anything they’re just AGAINST the ENEMY. Sometimes they get one dropped into their laps like on 9/11. Sometimes they gotta make their own. Communists. Immigrants.
At this point, they’re even happy to create their own out of queer college liberals. They were NEVER EVER going to vote R anyway. They know they can stir a REE out of them with legislation like this and then use the response as fodder for “America used to be strong and now it’s full of soyboy cucks.”
The arrogance of the Democrats is that they think Republican politicians are just stupid. Some are, but like if they’re so dumb, why haven’t the Dems been able to get more than 8 years? If your opponent is borderline mentally impaired, but you’re neck in neck in what is absolutely a competition of wits, what HARD reality are you failing to accept?
You want to know how to defuse the strategy? Don’t take the bait. It’d be one thing if it was in any way real. It isn’t. Don’t take the clickbait. Don’t feed the trolls. Don’t let someone take a picture of anyone with blue hair having a meltdown.
Yeah everyone should just let Republican lawmakers do whatever they want, no matter how outrageous, without discussing or complaining. Because that totally doesn’t normalize their outrageous behavior.
You believe this legislation is being put forward with the intention for it to be codified into law?
No (only because as you mentioned it’s not going to fly at the current time. They absolutely would if they could). That does not mean I think ignoring it is less harmful than calling it out.
My human, you have to know that they submitted this bill knowing full well it hasn’t got any chance of being taken seriously on the floor. There’s only one reason a lawmaker would even draft a bill like this, and that one reason is to get attention. A shiny bauble to distract us all. Any stage magician can tell you that magic is all about misdirection. If I’ve got you staring at the card in my left hand, you don’t notice the deck in my right hand. So, the thing you should be doing, is asking what they’ve got hidden up their sleeve.
Repeating something does not make it more correct
They’ve never needed pictures before, and they don’t need pictures now. Hell, even the iconic meme picture is taken from a video of a woman speaking normally - they just used an unflattering frame to discredit her. This isn’t a ploy to get a photo op of the left being mad, it’s another small push of the republican boundaries. Enough “joke” bills about overbearing punishments for minor offenses made by people their party doesn’t like, and they’ll be primed enough to fully support the real thing. We’re already there for a large portion of the republican base.
Republicans have a massive robust propaganda machine that flat out lies to their voters and they don’t question it. Obviously democrats have a ton of problems but the way you are framing that is disgustingly dishonest.
Are you saying that the reason the Dems aren’t trouncing the Republicans at every turn is because they won’t flat out lie to their voters?
And, if so, do you feel that the Dems have been honest about Gaza, and the way they have characterized the campus protests?
I’m not saying “both parties are equally bad”, I’m just saying that many of the justifications that Dems give for why the “mentality inferior Republicans” regularly beat them are really more of soothing stories than well-considered fact.
My whole thesis is that they’re not stupid. They’re dangerous. There IS method behind the madness, and this fairy tale we tell ourselves that they’re stupid is harmful to Democratic chances, because if they’re “just stupid” then you don’t see the plan and methodology… And if you can’t see the plan and methodology then you can’t develop an effective response to it.
So, I’m telling you what it is, and asking you to just think critically about things for even 1 second after you hear them and instead of throwing up your hands and wailing, ask basic questions like “why? Who is the audience? What response do they expect, and from who? How does that further their cause?” This particular example is easy-mode.
It’s so dumb, but this I’d the same base that was excited about Mexico paying for the wall.
I swear the federal governments that killed off entire populations of native Americans and authorized the recapture of escaped slaves were less childish and vindictive than today’s GOP.
Same group. They just changed their target from black people to woke people.
Woke includes minorities and women.
And there it is: a concentration camp/gulag for political “undesirables.”
Still think The Republican Party politicians ain’t literal fucking Nazis?
Fuck Putin, by the way.
We need a similar bill that would send anyone convicted of unlawful activity in the US Capital since January 5th of 2021 to Siberia.
Send them to Somalia, where they can experience a truly small government country with very conservative social views.
Better yet, the center of the sun. We don’t need them radicalized any more than they are. Somalians would pick up on their ignorance and exploit the shit out of them.
I say, make them the sun’s problem. There’s nothing that 27,000,000° Fahrenheit can’t solve.
Well firing them into the sun is extremely difficult, and resource intensive. Sending them on a one way trip to Somalia isn’t. There are plenty people who are far more radicalized than them there as it is. So they can go be radicals in Somalia, where they have no influence, power, protection, and most will hate them as a default. They will most likely just never be heard from again.
Pretty sure there are some rules about not forcibly relocating US citizens to foreign war zones. Ah, who am I kidding, rules don’t apply to the GOP anymore.
The ICC in The Hague will probably bar tha- what? they don’t recognise that court? Oh well.
Good luck over there.
People who don’t agree with war should go fight in a war. Am I reading this right?
Even worse: people who object to genocide should be forced to go to a war zone unarmed. And not just any war zone, one completely controlled by a fascist apartheid regime whose armed forces are deliberately targeting aid workers, healthcare workers, journalists and other unarmed people either keeping Palestinians alive, showing the world what the regime is doing, or both.
Also, wouldn’t it be foolish to send a bunch of angry young people to the country that they are supporting?
Seems like that would make it extra easy for Hamas to recruit American students, especially after they get to experience the horror first hand.
did the Weimar Republic also have a “lol jk” stage of fascism
Remember, this is not only the kind of shit that would get proposed but would be the kind of shit that would pass in a future Republican controlled state with Fuhrer Trump at the helm.
It sounds ridiculous and insane now, but remember, there are representatives that actually believe in this, and don’t think it’s rhetoric.
Their voter base as well would happily see “the other” carted off, in good fascist fashion.
It’s just the price they pay for my freedom. /s
All the GOP does anymore is block useful bills when they can and shitpost the rest of the time.
Israel won’t let journalists and food into the gaza, you think they’re going to let a bunch of US college students in? Besides they’re too old for Israel to kill.
Just wait until they find out that date rape is “unlawful activity”, so their sons all start getting sent .
Better start drafting that carve out for congressional family members.
Foreign volunteers are restricted from entering Gaza. If we are allowed to bring supplies, it may not be a bad idea. I wouldn’t mind getting send there, I have no other way of sneaking in.
Ordinarily, I’d agree with you, but the IDF is intentionally targeting aid workers, so even if they let you in, they may well murder you for trying to help save Palestinian lives.
Not saying that you shouldn’t still help if you’re willing to risk your life to save lives, just that you REALLY need to know what you’re signing up for and that forcing anyone to is ABSOLUTELY cruel and unusual punishment and almost definitely itself a war crime.
Jfc, just when I thought people were as dumb as our species can get
GOP’ers are the fucking worst. Maybe they should go move to Israel and have a stab at killing babies. On second thought, they’d probably like that since the kids have been born already and are brown.
Even a broken clock is right twice a day. Terrorist supporters can do it from the ground in Gaza. Start with the purple hair ones.
Ah so it’s not about rights and freedoms, it’s about the right opinions and the freedom of your side. The opinions of hypocrites can and should be discarded.
You have the right to peacefully protest. That’s not what’s going to get you shipped away.
What we have here though is far from peaceful and it’s far from a protest. These are terrorist camps harrassing people for their ethnicity and beliefs and based on the arrest records that we’re seeing, they’re being heavily influenced by non-students and bad actors.
The opinions of useful idiots should not be considered.
What’s your policy on useless idiots? It’s a time sensitive question because I just saw this opinion I’m not sure what to do with
They’re A rapidly growing subset of the useful version. And we are seeing repeatedly across college campuses where these idiots don’t know what they’re even protesting for or against. The number I’ve seen interviewed who can’t identify which river or sea they are chanting about would be funny if they weren’t promoting a genocide.
It is a fine line between useful and useless though, if you’re not sure where you fall the default is useless.
Imagine caring about the suffering of others for no good reason.
Sure, let’s get those hostages released and Hamas out of power so the Palestinians can actually have a chance at a peaceful life.
As someone who is sympathetic to the legal and moral Palestinian resistance by Hamas and other factions, I wouldn’t mind going there and helping out.
You should book a ticket and go. Plenty of flights to Tel Aviv, quick ride to the border. It’s not a terrible trip. I’m sure you’ll be welcome with open arms and I doubt the IDF would mind the extra ammunition being spent 👍
Don’t understand how this troll doesn’t get banned. Spouts the most rage bait shit.
Banning fact-based opinions that are contrary the group think. That’s my fascist. Nope. Not at all.
The IDF allows dyed hair now? Seems out of character.
They’re welcoming and inclusive but they’re not letting the pro Hamasites in, that’s just a bit too accepting.
pro Hamasites
Student protesters are not pro-Hamas. Few Palestinians are even pro-Hamas. Most Palestinians are under 18 and couldn’t even have voted for Hamas 18 years ago. There have been no elections since then.
Protesters are against killing thousands of innocent men, women, and children by bombing literally everything. That’s it. That’s the issue. If you think it’s OK to bomb children, say so, because that’s what protesters are against. So if you’re against the protesters, you’re for bombing innocents.
C’mon don’t be foolish. We’ve all seen the green headbands. We’ve all seen the signs. We’ve all seen the intifada chants.
I’m not saying they all are but enough of them are that staying among them pretty clearly demonstrates that you don’t have a problem with what they’re saying.
We’ve all seen
Don’t try to tell people what they’ve seen.
clearly demonstrates that you don’t have a problem with what they’re saying.
Now that is foolish rhetoric. Protesters can’t control who walks among them. There are counter protesters who walk among them, too. Does that mean the anti-genocide protesters don’t have a problem with the counter protesters? Nonsense.
The vast majority of student protesters are anti-genocide of Palestinians. Full stop. If you say or imply otherwise, you are not arguing in good faith.
Even civil rights protesters in the 1960’s had individuals among them who thought they should “kill all whites”. That doesn’t say a thing about the ones who were there simply for equal rights. It’s a fallacy to ascribe the beliefs of the extreme minority to the beliefs of the majority just because they walked or sat together.
If you haven’t seen it then you would Have to be intentionally avoiding. But you’re even offended by that. Just proves that you don’t care about reality. You just care about pushing the propaganda.
Protesters can’t control who walks around them? That’s the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard. It’s really really really easy to walk away from the guy wearing the swastika or the green headband. That you’re denying this basic reality again, just shows that you just want to push the propaganda.
The vast majority of protesters are clearly ill-informed if they think there’s a genocide going on. I’m pretty safe in believing that you’ve intentionally avoided the follow-up from the icj president who went out of her way to clarify that they did not find it plausible Israel as committing a genocide. Stop pushing lies.
Supporting palestine is not supporting terrorists. Can you tell me how many palestinian civilian casualties are recorded till now in Gaza? Can you tell me what is the number or Israelis who died as a result of IDF invasion into Gaza?
